Pine Island Post Office

665 County Route 1, Pine Island, NY 10969

Contact Numbers

Phone: 845-258-4798
Fax: 845-258-0003
TTY: 877-889-2457
Toll-Free: 1-800-Ask-USPS® (275-8777)

Retail Hours

Lobby Hours
PO Box Access Available

Monday 24 hours
Tuesday 24 hours
Wednesday 24 hours
Thursday 24 hours
Friday 24 hours
Saturday 24 hours
Sunday 24 hours

Last Collection Times

Monday 5:00pm
Tuesday 5:00pm
Wednesday 5:00pm
Thursday 5:00pm
Friday 5:00pm
Saturday 12:00pm
Sunday Closed

*This facility does not process US Passports applications or renewals. Check nearby locations below.

  • Burial Flags
  • Business Line
  • Duck Stamps
  • General Delivery
  • Money Orders (Domestic)
  • Money Orders (Inquiry)
  • Money Orders (International)
  • Pickup Accountable Mail
  • Pickup Hold Mail
  • PO Box Online
  • Lot Parking

Visit our Links Page for Holiday Schedule, Change of Address, Hold Mail/Stop Delivery, PO Box rentals and fees, and Available Jobs.

*Please call to verify information. Is anything incorrect? Let us know here

Nearby Post Offices:

958 County Rt 517
2.0 miles away

New Milford
3 Jockey Hollow Rd Ste 2
3.1 miles away

83 County Highway 22
3.2 miles away

2097 County Route 1
3.5 miles away


*Comments below are not read by postal employees. Please do not post personal information.

*By clicking Submit, you agree to our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use.


The postal service is the absolute worst way to ship a package or letter if you want timely delivery. this includes 1-3 day priortity . The items go thru a "LOOP" which is back and forth between sorting facilities for days on end. The only way to get prompt delivery is to use Fed Ex or UPS. The TV advertisements are an absolute JOKE and falsely show prompt deliveries. In other words, You promote FALSE ADERTVERTISING. I believe that's against the law. I use the post office to mail out checks to pay bills , that way I know they are post marked and WILL ARRIVE LATE to allow me time to gather the funds to cover the bills. Bravo for that.

* is not a part of, or affiliated with, the official United States Postal Service (USPS).